Dawn Marie Birnbaum
(1976 - 1993)

Dawn Marie Birnbaum

Indiana, United States of America

PA, United States of America
March 23, 1993

This is a memorial website for Dawn Marie Birnbaum, a 17-year old runaway from the Elan School in Poland Spring, Maine, who was murdered by James Robert Cruz, Jr., on or about March 23, 1993. The webmaster is of no relation to Dawn or any member of her family, but she wanted Dawn to be remembered. The webmaster was a doctoral student in Education at Penn State when Dawn's body was found. She will never forget reading the headlines of the local paper about what was found on that cold March morning back in 1993. What happened to Dawn should serve as a cautionary tale to other teenagers.

Dawn Marie Birnbaum, according to research done by the webmaster, had originally been from Gary, Indiana, and had led a troubled life, running away many times from home and from foster homes. She had been a ward of the state of Indiana, and had been sent to the Elan School, a home for runaway and troubled teenagers, in Poland Spring, Maine.

On or about March 22, 1993, Dawn and other teens from the Elan School were taken to a nearby mall to watch a movie and left there. It appears no counselor or other chaperone was there to watch this group, though they knew Dawn was a flight risk. When the time came to pick up the group of teens, Dawn wasn't there. She had run away again, this time to a nearby truck stop, the Dysart trucking stop, where she had hitched a ride with a truck driver. She had wanted to hitchhike to California (apparently) to see a friend of hers, and she made some calls from a pay phone inside the truck stop. Lacking paper, she wrote the numbers she was calling on her hand. This would prove instrumental in tracing who she was and where she came from, as she had no identification when she was found.

Dawn hitched a ride with a long-distance trucker, James Robert Cruz, Jr., who worked for the New Century Trucking Company out of Waterford, Ohio. A married 36 year old truck driver with three children and an expectant pregnant wife at home, Cruz had sex with Dawn in the truck and transported her across state lines. He evidently feared being caught, because he strangled her to death with a length of nylon rope. She was found half-clothed, wearing a heavy sweater and socks, with her hands tied behind her and a length of rope still around her neck, in a snowbank off Route 550 and Route 26, Centre County, Pennsylvania, near the Milesburg, PA exit of Interstate 80, the major road that runs across Pennsylvania and across the country.

Dawn was identified through painstaking detective work on the part of PA state trooper William F. Madden, who unfortunately died in 2000 at age 49 from cancer. FBI Special Agent Randy Cohick also assisted in the investigation. The key factor in the investigation was matching fuel receipts from the Bestway Travel Plaza in Milesburg with fuel receipts from the Dysart plaza in Maine. There was one match: James Robert Cruz, Jr., who had bought fuel at both places.

Tire tracks found near Dawn's body indicated that she'd been dropped off there by someone in a tractor-trailer, and plaster casts were made of the tire tracks. The casts eventually matched those on a rig driven by Cruz, and a single hair found in the carpeting on the passenger side door matched that of the unidentified victim, who by then had been identified as Dawn Marie Birnbaum. Dawn's mother, Nancy Lindemann, was sent for, and visited the Mondock Funeral Home in Bellefonte, PA, where her daughter's body was being kept. When Steve Mondock, the funeral director, pulled the pink sheet back from Dawn's face, Mrs. Lindemann identified her and began to cry. When she learned that the people of Bellefonte, PA, who were outraged that a young woman had been brutally murdered and dumped on a snowbank in their midst, they "adopted" Dawn as one of their own, and arranged for a plot in their cemetery. Eerily enough, before they found out who she was, they decided to call her "Spring Dawn" because she was found in Spring Township at dawn.

Despite the prosecutor's call for the death penalty, James Robert Cruz, Jr. was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole. He is presently incarcerated at Graterford State Prison north of Philadelphia.

Before Cruz was incarcerated, young women were constantly being found dead along area highways that Cruz traveled across Ohio and other states, in the same manner as Dawn Birnbaum. After his arrest, these deaths stopped. In the TV series "THE FBI FILES", the episode "A STRANGER IN TOWN" profiles the Dawn Marie Birnbaum case, and investigators still strongly feel that Cruz may be responsible for the deaths of at least 40 other women, though this has never been proven. However, it is definitely notable that after Dawn's disappearance and murder were solved, these other young women, of about Dawn's age, were no longer being killed.

On Dec. 4, 2008, Dawn's mother, Nancy Lindemann, died at age 55 at the Altoona Hospital. She is buried in Union Cemetery, Bellefonte, PA, beside her beloved daughter Dawn Marie, whom she loved so much and tried to help.

Rest in peace, Dawn!


If these newspaper links do not open up on their own, copy and paste the link into your browser):

"Jury Weighs Local Man's Case", THE VINDICATOR(June 14, 19994), at: http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=-MxJAAAAIBAJ&sjid=AIUMAAAAIBAJ&pg=6131,8458998&dq=james+robert+cruz+jr&hl=en

Guest Book Wall (What is this?)

Hover your mouse over the wall images to see each guest book entry.

Guest Book (73 entries)
I saw the FBI files episode about the murder of Dawn Birnbaum. What happened to Dawn upset me a lot. It is very disturbing to me. I am glad that her murderer is going to be jailed for life.
September 2nd, 2015

I heard about your story through FBI Files on Netflix as well. My heart goes out to you and your family. 22 years later, I know they still miss and love you. Praying for special peace for them.
Cindy Keith
August 24th, 2015
More than 20 years later, your story still makes an impression on me.
Hal Jones (None)
August 21st, 2015
I have no idea of why I enjoy these stories so much. It just hurts me that there are so many people out there that are evil, when some people want nothing more than for someone to help them. People loved you Dawn.
Clarence Jones
August 9th, 2015
Rest In peace so many years has past. You are not forgotten thanks for who ever set this website up.
July 20th, 2015
Your Contact Details

Remember to proofread. Once submitted, you will not be able to edit.

Select an icon to go along with your message.
Standard Icon - Default (Free)

Premium Icons - Optional ($5 each)

Adding a premium icon to the memorial helps make your comment standout. You can mark a birthday, leave a flower, or just show the family or friends of the person you are thinking of them. iLasting uses the revenue generated from these icons to continually update the site.



"So sorry for your loss"
william Contreras
June 10th, 2015
"I am so sorry. I was in elan with you . Your story haunts me."
Tracy Hutchinson
August 23rd, 2014
"I am so glad to see how many people have lit candles and messages for Dawn since I first put this site up. I was in grad school at PSU when she was killed and remember it well. She reminded me of my cousin, who also was troubled and ran away."
Janice Harrison
July 22nd, 2014
"Dawn, your story broke my heart like no other. You were only trying to push your boundaries and spread your wings like all normal teenagers. I wish I could have known you, because I know I could have loved you."
Jim Bowman
June 26th, 2013
"I put up this site for Dawn some time ago, and Fran Lupo and other friends of Dawn's from Elan sponsored it. I check in here every so often and am so amazed at how many candles and notes are left for Dawn."
Janice Harrison
June 17th, 2013
"It's amazing Dawn how you have affected and changed my life . I never knew you in life but since first hearing your story you ha e become like my own family . Thank you for story Dawn its o.e I shall carry with me all my life ."
Rick Harker
June 7th, 2013
"Dear Dawn after watching your sad end on the FBI files I wanted to look into your story some more & found this lovely tribute site to you. I hope you are in peace now sweety. Forever free, young & beautiful.xx"
Annette Hollingsworth
December 9th, 2012
"Hi Aunt Dawn, I never got to meet you, but I wish that I could have. I'm going to be 18 soon, Aunt Dawn. And graduating high school in June. I wish I could have met you. I love you, Aunt Dawn. Rest In Peace. And, say hi to grandma for me please."
Rebecca Lindemann
October 20th, 2012
"Dear Dawn your story had touched my heart and life since I saw it on the fbi files tv show in 2000.I wish I had the chance to meet you in person and have rescued you.You are now in the sky with God and his angels and saints."
Lucy Benitez
June 17th, 2012
"Dawn, you will always have a special place in my heart. i named my daughter after you. she is now 14. I will always miss you, and one day see you again, my friend"
ellen williamson
May 16th, 2011


You have 250 characters left.

Share With Family & Friends


to multiple people.

Get Updates

Add your email below to be notified when visitors post to this memorial.

Share this memorial with people by sending them this link: